Fire and rehire is about to get much riskier for employers

Insight from an HR consultant in Suffolk on the fire and rehire law change arriving in January 2027 and what it means for your business.

I’ve been talking to a lot of business owners recently who’ve made contract changes by ending someone’s employment and bringing them back on new terms.

Most didn’t even realise they were doing something the law treats as “fire and rehire.”

From January 2027, that approach is going to carry far more serious consequences than it does today.

The financial exposure alone could be significant. Here’s what you need to know.

What counts as fire and rehire

In simple terms, fire and rehire happens when you end someone’s employment because they won’t agree to a change in their contract, and then you offer them their job back on the new terms you wanted.

It’s been used by businesses of all sizes for years. Sometimes it’s a deliberate strategy. More often, it’s a business owner who just needs to make a change and doesn’t see another way forward.

Up to now, an employee with enough service could challenge this as unfair dismissal. A tribunal would then look at whether you’d acted reasonably. It was risky, but it was still an option.

That’s about to change.

The new rules from January 2027

Fire and rehire will be classified as automatically unfair dismissal. That’s the same category reserved for dismissals linked to whistleblowing or pregnancy.

Two things make this particularly serious for smaller employers.

First, there’s no minimum length of service required for an employee to bring a claim. Someone who started last week could take action against you.

Second, the statutory cap on compensation for unfair dismissal is being removed. That applies to all unfair dismissal claims from January, including automatically unfair ones. There will be no ceiling on what a tribunal can award.

Which contract changes are affected

The law refers to “restricted variations.” In plain language, these are changes to specific contractual terms that an employee hasn’t agreed to. The list includes:

  • Pay, including how it’s calculated
  • Pension arrangements
  • Working hours
  • Holiday entitlement
  • Shift patterns (final details are still being confirmed)

There’s one more. Adding a new clause to someone’s contract that gives you the right to make any of the above changes without their agreement will also be caught by the new rules.

If you dismiss someone and re-engage them with any of those terms altered, that’s automatically unfair dismissal under the new law.

What about other types of contract changes

Changes to things like job title, location or duties aren’t on the restricted list. You can still technically use dismissal and re-engagement for those.

But don’t assume that makes it straightforward. Those changes will still need to pass the ordinary unfair dismissal test. And from January, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal drops to six months, with no cap on compensation either.

A tribunal hearing one of these cases will want to understand your reasons for the change, whether you consulted properly with the employee, and whether you offered anything in return. You’ll need to demonstrate that you handled the whole process reasonably.

Is there any exception at all

There is one, but it’s narrow. If your business is facing genuine, severe financial difficulty that threatens its survival, and you’ve exhausted all other options, you may have a defence.

The key word is survival. Wanting to cut costs or boost margins won’t qualify. This exception is designed for situations where the business genuinely cannot continue operating without making the change.

Practical steps to take now

If you’ve ever made contract changes by ending and restarting someone’s employment, or if you’re considering doing so in the future, it’s worth getting your house in order well before January.

Start by reviewing your existing contracts. If there are changes you know you need to make to pay, hours, pensions or benefits, the safest route is proper consultation with your employees. Aim for genuine agreement rather than assuming you can fall back on dismissal and re-engagement if they say no.

Think carefully about any planned restructuring. If it involves altering the terms listed above, you’ll need to build in enough time for meaningful consultation. Rushing this process or skipping steps will leave you exposed.

Document everything. If you do need to make changes, keep clear records of your consultation process, the business reasons behind the change, and any alternatives you considered.

As part of our HR consultancy services in Suffolk, we regularly help business owners work through exactly these kinds of situations. Getting it right at the planning stage saves a lot of stress later on.

Questions worth asking yourself

Have a think about where your business stands right now:

  • Have you ever ended and restarted someone’s employment to change their contract terms?
  • Are there any upcoming changes to pay, hours or benefits that your team might push back on?
  • Do your current contracts contain clauses that allow you to vary terms unilaterally?
  • If a change were challenged at tribunal, could you evidence a fair consultation process?

If any of those give you pause, it’s worth having a conversation sooner rather than later.

How we can help

We work with business owners to review contracts, plan consultations and make sure any changes are handled properly and lawfully.

As an outsourced HR consultant in Suffolk, I can look at your current setup and give you clear, honest advice on what needs attention before January 2027.

If you’d like to talk any of this through, get in touch for a free, confidential chat. No obligation, just a straightforward conversation about where you stand.

Call us on 01473 653000 or email hello@pshumanresources.co.uk.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Latest News

Archives

Book a FREE 30 minute consultation with a senior HR advisor

Book a free 30 minute consultation with a senior HR advisor